226 is quite hard to beat. Why no love for the scar? too much plastic?
As for the Kimber... I love that gun, but unfortunately, was the only gun in the collection to have major issues right out of the box.
First off with Kimber...I want a Raptor pro stainless more than any non custom 1911 out there. I just cannot dig the 2 year warranty. They have a lot of QC issues out of the box but are good with fixing them. Its just hard to sell a guy a kimber when the springfields in the next case have a better warranty.
I love the idea of the scar, and if I had an extra 3k I would have a scar heavy FDE, the recoil (less) system on there is amazing, even in full auto it feels like a .22.
As a toy/plinker its an awesome gun.
I just can't get on board with a battle rifle that is so proprietary.