Gay Marriage

[dude...]

Just wanted to say good work to our zany american cousins for being all progressive and getting it done. I hope that australia gets its shit together and follows suit sharpish

[barcodebilly]

I don't get why people care so much on the opposing side.  I'm glad everyone can get married as they please now.

[Alex.]

FUCK QUEERS!

I kid, obviously. Have you guys heard about people getting a divorce because of the ruling? They're like... "Well if marriage doesn't mean anything anymore, why even bother?!" How fucking mental must you be to have that thought process?

[DontcallmeKenneth]

Because people are assholes. I want front row seats to the pastor that said he would burn himself alive in protest.

[hugh.]

I think people are angry cause it'll be harder to get a venue for their straight wedding and everyone would rather go to a gay one cause they're so much fun.

We recently legalized it in Ireland too and the only thing more fun than an Irish wedding is a gay Irish wedding.

Fuck yeah the craic will be mighty

[Prodigal Son]

The old guard is almost dead. Either we make it out of Sinai or we don't know anything else and it might as well be an exit.

[Narcoleptic Insomniac]

I'm glad for our gay brothers and sisters.

[master]

I'm glad it happened, but the route that was taken is a slippery slope. Using the 14th Amendment to go around the 10th Amendment will make for some interesting case law in the future as it is applied to other unintended situations.

[Kinchy]

What does that mean for people who don't know what the amendments are?

[master]

What does that mean for people who don't know what the amendments are?

I'm sure that you know that the US Constitution is the highest law, so everything we do must be in line with the intent of the text (not the interpretation of the text, as some politicians like to think).

The 10th Amendment reads: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people."

This means that if the Constitution doesn't specifically give power to the Federal government on an issue, the States are responsible for that issue. All 50 states have the authority to handle these issues as they see fit, and can handle them in 50 different ways if each state so chooses.

The 14th Amendment is a long one, but the passage of Section 1 applied in this case states: "... No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States... nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."

The Supreme Court ruled that this passage of the 14th trumped the 10th in this case. This logic, now written as Case Law, can be legally applied in future cases where any person feels that a State's law denies them equal protection and can override State law.

It will be interesting to see how this case law is applied in the future.

[torontoflatlander]

I just liked reading the comments about bigoted Americans being pissed off and wanting to run to Canada.

[DontcallmeKenneth]

As if other countries will welcome amrican bigotry.

[Narcoleptic Insomniac]

I just liked reading the comments about bigoted Americans being pissed off and wanting to run to Canada.

You've had legal same sex marriage for about a decade now, correct?

[GUMP_]

Stoked on America doing the right thing for the gay/bi/lesbians.

[torontoflatlander]

I just liked reading the comments about bigoted Americans being pissed off and wanting to run to Canada.

You've had legal same sex marriage for about a decade now, correct?

Correct.

What's better is that it's also pride week in TO at the same time this is all going on in the states. Downtown will basically be rainbows and nipples for the next week and a bit. Crazy influx of money comes into the city too. Good times had by all.